Football

DOES LAMINE YAMAL DESERVE TO BE CALLED THE HEIR OF MESSI?

A young winger in a blue and red striped shirt dribbling past a defender in a white and green kit during a night match in a packed stadium

THE NEXT MESSI OR A LEGEND IN HIS OWN RIGHT? WHY LAMINE YAMAL DESERVES TO BUILD HIS OWN FOOTBALL LEGACY

At just 16 years old during Euro 2024, Lamine Yamal had already attracted worldwide attention with his extraordinary performances for Barcelona and Spain. His technical ability, confidence on the ball, and maturity in important matches led many football supporters to compare him with Lionel Messi.

The comparisons were understandable. Both players developed at Barcelona’s famous La Masia academy, both are left-footed, and both have demonstrated an exceptional ability to create opportunities from the right side of the attack.

Yamal also wore Barcelona’s number 19 shirt, a number Messi had worn during the early stages of his career.

But an important question deserves consideration: Is Lamine Yamal really the next Lionel Messi, or should he be allowed to develop his own identity without carrying the expectations of another football legend?

His talent is undeniable, but becoming an exceptional footballer is different from becoming a copy of one of the greatest players in history.

  Why the World Compares Lamine Yamal to Lionel Messi

The connection between Yamal and Messi begins with their development at Barcelona.

Both players came through La Masia, an academy known for developing technically gifted footballers who understand the club’s style of possession-based football.

Their playing characteristics have also attracted attention. Yamal is naturally left-footed and frequently operates on the right wing. From that position, he can move inside, challenge defenders, create scoring opportunities, or shoot with his stronger foot.

This playing style reminds many supporters of Messi’s early years at Barcelona.

However, Yamal has characteristics that make him different. His ability to accelerate past defenders, maintain control in tight spaces, and deliver dangerous passes has helped establish him as a distinctive attacking talent.

His breakthrough became particularly memorable during Euro 2024.

At 16 years and 338 days old, Yamal became the youngest player ever to appear in a European Championship match. He continued making history throughout the tournament, scoring a spectacular goal against France in the semi-final.

That goal made him the youngest goalscorer in European Championship history.

Spain eventually defeated England 2–1 in the final, with Yamal providing an assist for Nico Williams’s opening goal. He finished the tournament with four assists and received the Young Player of the Tournament award.

These achievements explain why the football world began discussing him as one of the most exciting young players of his generation.

Nevertheless, his achievements should be appreciated on their own rather than treated as evidence that he will necessarily follow Messi’s career path.

  Why Comparing Yamal to Messi Can Be Unfair

Lionel Messi’s greatness was not established through one tournament or a single outstanding season.

His career developed over many years at the highest level. He won domestic championships, Champions League titles, individual awards, and international trophies while consistently performing against the strongest opponents in world football.

At Barcelona, Messi eventually became the central figure of an extraordinary generation.

Yamal, by comparison, was still at the beginning of his professional journey during Euro 2024. Although his early achievements were exceptional, he had not yet experienced the demands of maintaining elite performances over an entire career.

This difference is important.

When a young player is constantly compared with a football legend, every performance can become an unfair examination. An excellent match may lead to exaggerated expectations, while an ordinary performance can generate criticism that would be unreasonable for someone of his age.

Young footballers need time to develop their physical strength, tactical understanding, decision-making, and ability to handle pressure.

They also need the freedom to make mistakes.

Yamal should not have to reproduce Messi’s achievements to prove that he is a special footballer.

Messi’s career belongs to Messi. Yamal deserves the opportunity to build something that belongs entirely to him.

   What Does Yamal Need to Become a Great Player?

Natural talent is an important starting point, but remaining successful at the highest level requires consistency and continuous development.

There are three important factors that could influence Yamal’s future.

First, maintaining his physical condition.

Professional football places enormous demands on the body, particularly for players who compete regularly for both club and country. Managing his workload, recovering properly, and avoiding serious injuries will be important throughout his development.

Second, continuing to improve his footballing ability.

Defenders will increasingly study Yamal’s movements and attempt to limit his influence. He will need to develop different attacking solutions, improve his finishing, and become more unpredictable when facing opponents who understand his preferred movements.

Third, maintaining the right mentality.

Becoming famous at a young age can create enormous expectations. Having the support of family, coaches, teammates, and the club will be important in helping him remain focused on football rather than outside pressure.

Messi also experienced difficult periods throughout his career. His achievements were built through years of development, adaptation, and consistent performances.

Yamal should be judged by his own progress, not by how quickly he can reach another player’s achievements.

 Lionel Messi and Lamine Yamal: Two Different Beginnings

Although their careers share some similarities, their early achievements reflect different circumstances and football generations.

Category Lionel Messi Lamine Yamal

Barcelona First-Team Debut

October 2004, aged 17 April 2023, aged 15

Academy

La Masia La Masia

Preferred Foot

Left

Left

Early Playing Position Attacking forward

Right winger

Major International Achievement Before 18 No senior international title

Euro 2024 champion

Historic Achievement Became a key Barcelona first-team player Youngest player and goalscorer in Euro history

Source: Historical records compiled from FC Barcelona and UEFA’s official Euro 2024 records.

The comparison shows that both players experienced remarkable beginnings at Barcelona. However, Yamal achieved international success at an exceptionally young age, while Messi’s greatest international achievements came later in his career.

These are different journeys, and neither needs to be measured against the other.

  My Perspective

I admire Lamine Yamal because his performances at such a young age have been genuinely impressive, but I also believe football supporters should be careful about placing too much pressure on him. When I was 17, I was still learning about life and making mistakes, so I cannot imagine facing the judgment of millions of people after every football match. I hope people allow him to grow naturally because the world does not need another Messi; it deserves to discover how great Lamine Yamal can become in his own way.

What do you think about the comparison between Yamal and Messi? Do you believe Yamal has the potential to reach a similar level, or should supporters stop comparing them and appreciate two different football talents? For me, the most exciting possibility is watching Yamal create a legacy that belongs entirely to himself.